Choosing an iRacing teammate should not take an entire season of guesswork and drama. With a lightweight, repeatable tryout process, you can turn gut feelings into clear observations and decide quickly whether to continue or move on.
The minimum viable tryout (2 practices + 1 race)
You don’t need a six‑week academy to know whether someone fits your team. Two focused practice sessions and one official or hosted race are enough to reveal most major patterns.
Use this simple structure:
- Practice 1: Baseline and communication
- Run together in an open practice, same car and combo.
- Watch how they warm up, handle traffic, and respond to basic coaching or feedback.
- Practice 2: Race prep and adjustments
- Treat this like pre‑race practice: fuel runs, qualifying sims, and short stints.
- See whether they adjust based on what you discussed after Practice 1.
- Race 1: Real conditions under pressure
- Join the same official or league race, or run a serious hosted event.
- Focus on decision‑making, composure, and how they handle bad luck.
During each session, keep a few notes (or use a simple scorecard) instead of relying on memory. Patterns, not one‑off moments, should drive your decision.
The 5 key compatibility checks
These checks matter more than raw speed because they affect every stint, strategy call, and season you run together.
1. Consistency over single‑lap pace
Raw pace is nice; lap‑in, lap‑out stability wins more races and survives more splits.
Look for:
- Small lap time spread once they’re up to speed, especially in clean air.
- Few self‑inflicted errors when tyres wear or fuel loads change.
- Willingness to back off a couple tenths to keep the car safe and predictable.
If someone is fast but constantly binning it in practice, that’s a liability in endurance and league racing.
2. Incident avoidance and decision‑making
Incidents are not just bad luck; they’re often the result of patterns in judgment.
Observe:
- How they handle side‑by‑side situations (do they leave space or squeeze on corner exit).
- Their approach to lapping and being lapped in multiclass.
- Whether they bail out of obviously doomed moves or double down into chaos.
Good teammates know when to concede and survive, and they treat Safety Rating and clean driving as part of the job, not optional fluff.
3. Communication style under stress
You’re not just evaluating what they say but how they say it when things go wrong.
Check for:
- Clarity and brevity in voice comms (short, calm calls instead of panic essays mid‑corner).
- Their tone after mistakes—do they own it, or instantly blame others or “netcode.”
- Whether they listen to spotter or teammate information and adjust.
A teammate who can communicate clearly while staying composed will save you more races than a quiet hotlap specialist.
4. Scheduling reliability
Speed doesn’t help if they never show up when it counts.
Look at:
- Do they arrive when they said they would for both practices and the race.
- Do they confirm or give notice if something changes.
- Are they realistic about their long‑term availability (work, family, time zone).
Treat reliability like a performance metric: a slightly slower but always‑present teammate is usually more valuable than an unreliable rocket.
5. Improvement mindset
A growth mindset means performance can trend up over time instead of stagnating.
Evaluate:
- Do they ask questions, review replays, or show curiosity about setups and strategy.
- How they react to constructive feedback—defensive, or appreciative and proactive.
- Whether they self‑diagnose issues (“I’m overdriving entry here”) and try fixes.
Teammates who enjoy learning will naturally close gaps, adapt to new cars, and help push the whole group forward.
Red flags vs green flags
Use these as quick signals during your tryout. One red flag isn’t an automatic “no,” but multiple consistent signs are.
Common green flags
- Shows up early, loads into the session, and gets ready without being chased.
- Joins voice chat, introduces themselves, and asks basic questions about team preferences.
- Takes responsibility after an incident and suggests how to avoid repeats.
- Chooses safe, measured overtakes instead of divebombs in the first few laps.
- Asks for and offers help—setups, lines, or race craft ideas—without ego.
Common red flags
- No‑shows or late joins with vague excuses during the tryout itself.
- Blames every incident on “idiots,” “netcode,” or “bad luck” but never on their decisions.
- Refuses to run practice stints, only wants to qualify or hotlap.
- Talks over others constantly or goes silent in critical moments (pit in, blue flags, restarts).
- Ignores agreed strategy (fuel, tyres, risk level) the moment the green flag drops.
If your notes show more red than green across the three sessions, that’s a clear signal not to force the fit.
How to end a tryout professionally
Not every tryout ends with a “yes,” and that’s fine. The goal is clarity, not universal acceptance.
Use this simple approach:
- Decide quickly
- Within a day or two of your race, review your notes and make a firm decision.
- Avoid dragging things out with “maybe later” if you already know it isn’t a fit.
- Be honest but respectful
- Thank them for their time and effort.
- Use neutral language focused on fit, not personal attacks.
- Offer a soft landing when possible
- Suggest they stay in the community Discord if the culture is fine but team seats are full.
- If appropriate, offer specific feedback they can use elsewhere.
Example message:
“Hey, thanks again for running those sessions and the race with us. After talking it over, we’ve decided not to move forward with a permanent spot right now. We’re looking for someone with a bit more [consistency / schedule overlap / experience in traffic], but we really appreciate the time and hope you find a team that matches your goals. If you’d like feedback or want to keep running casual sessions together, we’re happy to do that.”
Handling “no” this way protects your reputation and keeps doors open with other drivers who may be a better fit later.
Use a Teammate Vetting Scorecard
To make this process even easier, turn it into a simple checklist or scorecard. For each driver you test, rate:
- Consistency (practice and race)
- Incident rate and decision quality
- Comms clarity and attitude under stress
- Reliability across the three sessions
- Improvement from Practice 1 to Race 1
Connect with Us!
